Crotty's Cheesesteaks Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Crotty's Cheesesteaks, a delightful gem nestled at 8 Eastchester Rd, New Rochelle, NY. This eatery is redefining the cheesesteak experience, boasting an array of mouthwatering sandwiches that cater to every palate.
- The Sicilian: A savory mix of provolone, caramelized onions, and Italian hot peppers.
- The Rocky Cheesesteak: A juicy delight featuring mozzarella, homemade marinara, and fresh basil.
- Extreme Choices: For the adventurous, try the decadent Mac & Cheese Whiz or the spicy Wild Buffalo.
- Vegan Option: Delight in the Beyond Meat cheesesteaks that don't compromise on flavor.
Every bite resonates freshness and quality, while the inviting staff ensures you feel right at home. Whether dining in or taking away, Crotty's is more than just a meal—it's a memorable experience you'll crave again. Come savor the magic!
Cheesesteak Sandwiches
The Traditional
Whiz and caramelized onion
The BBQ Pit
Caramelized onions, signature BBQ sauce, and your choice of cheese
The New Yorker
Caramelized onions, grilled tomatoes, and Cheddar cheese
The Irishman
Cheddar cheese, caramelized onions, crispy bacon, mushrooms, and brown gravy
The French Dip
Side of warm au jus for dipping provolone cheese and caramelized onions
The Club
American cheese, caramelized onions, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo
The Steakhouse Cheesesteak
Gorgonzola, caramelized onions, cheese, & side of warm au jus for dipping
Caesar Wrap Cheesesteak
Served on a bed of fresh romaine, caramelized onions, and imported shredded Parmesan cheese topped with Crotty's creamy Caesar dressing
The Paulie
Provolone cheese and caramelized onions with the perfect amount of grilled bell peppers and jalapeños finely chopped
The Rocky Cheesesteak
Mozzarella cheese, caramelized onions, homemade marinara sauce, cheese, and basil topped with shaved Parmesan cheese
The Sicilian
Provolone cheese, caramelized onions, broccoli rabe, Italian hot peppers, and grilled tomatoes
The Vegan Cheesesteaks
Beyond meat, vegan cheese, and caramelized onions
The Custom Cheesesteak
The Traditional (Shortie)
caramelized onions and cheese whiz
The BBQ Pit (Shortie)
Caramelized onions, signature BBQ sauce, and your choice of cheese
The New Yorker (Shortie)
Caramelized onions, grilled tomatoes, and Cheddar cheese
The Irishman (Shortie)
Cheddar cheese, caramelized onions, crispy bacon, mushrooms, and brown gravy
The Frenchdip (Shortie)
Provolone cheese, caramelized onions, with a warm side of au jus for dipping
The Club (Shortie)
American cheese, caramelized onions, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo
The Steakhouse (Shortie)
Gorgonzola cheese, caramelized onions, & and side of warm au jus for dipping
Caesar Wrap Cheesesteak (Shortie)
Served on a bed of fresh romaine, caramelized onions, and imported shredded Parmesan cheese topped with Crotty's creamy Caesar dressing
The Paulie (Shortie)
Provolone cheese and caramelized onions with the perfect amount of grilled bell peppers and jalapeños finely chopped
The Rocky Cheesesteak (Shortie)
Mozzarella cheese, caramelized onions, homemade marinara sauce, cheese, and basil topped with shaved Parmesan cheese
The Sicilian (Shortie)
Provolone cheese, caramelized onions, broccoli rabe, Italian hot peppers, and grilled tomatoes
The Vegan Cheesesteaks (Shortie)
Beyond meat, vegan cheese, and caramelized onions
Cheesesteak Sandwiches (Shorties)
Extreme Cheesesteak Sandwiches
The Chili Philly Cheesesteak
American cheese, caramelized onions, and our homemade chili
The Mac & Cheese
Whiz, caramelized onions, mac & cheese, and crispy bacon
The Alpha Wolf
Provolone cheese, caramelized onions, crispy bacon, onion rings, jalapeño peppers, served with a side of of crotty's signature creamy onion vinaigrette
The Philly Hangover
American cheese, caramelized onions, bell peppers, two fried eggs, crispy bacon and tator tots
The Wild Buffalo
Blue cheese, caramelized onions, spicy buffalo sauce, jalapeño peppers, onion rings and coleslaw
The Chili Philly Cheesesteak (Shortie)
American cheese, caramelized onions, and our homemade chili
The Mac & Cheese (Shortie)
Whiz, caramelized onions, mac & cheese, and crispy bacon
The Alpha Wolf (Shortie)
Provolone cheese, caramelized onions, crispy bacon, onion rings, jalapeño peppers, served with a side of of crotty's signature creamy onion vinaigrette
The Philly Hangover (Shortie)
American cheese, caramelized onions, bell peppers, two fried eggs, crispy bacon and tator tots
The Wild Buffalo (Shortie)
Blue cheese, caramelized onions, spicy buffalo sauce, jalapeño peppers, onion rings and coleslaw
Extreme Cheesesteak Sandwiches (Shorties)
Burgers
Single CYO Burger
Create your own burger just the way you like!
Double CYO Burger
Create your own burger just the way you like!
Mushroom Swiss Burger Single Patty
A Single Philly Patty, with Melted Swiss and Grilled Mushrooms
Chili Cheese Burger Single Patty
Bacon Egg Cheese
Bacon Egg and American Cheese on a Brioche Roll or Toasted Hoagie. Add Saucy Rascal Hot Sauce at your request.
Steak Egg Cheese
Steak Egg and American Cheese on a Brioche roll or toasted Hoagie. Add Saucy Rascal Hot sauce at your request.
Breakfast Sandwich All Day
Kids
Traditional Cheesesteak Slider (No Onions) & Scoop Of French Fries
Upside Down Grilled Cheese & Scoop Of French Fries
With a scoop of french fries
Kids Homemade Chicken Fingers & Scoop Of French Fries
With a scoop of french fries
Signature Salad
Mixed greens, tomatoes, dried cranberries, & sunflower seeds topped with Gorgonzola cheese
Caesar Salad
Chopped romaine hearts, shaved Parmesan, and freshly toasted croutons topped with our homemade savory Caesar dressing
Crotty's House Salad
Mixed greens, tomatoes, red onions, and cucumber
Salads
Sides
Fries
Large order of crispy & fresh fries!
Disco Fries
Crispy fries, brown gravy, caramelized onions & whiz
Small Side Of Mac & Cheese
Crotty's uses 3 different cheeses and a homemade cheese sauce, topped with shaved Parmesan
Large Side Of Mac & Cheese
Crotty's uses 3 different cheeses and a homemade cheese sauce, topped with shaved Parmesan
Philly Cheese Steak Eggroll
Two Philly cheese steak eggrolls served with a side cheese sauce
Onion Rings
Perfectly seasoned large order of onion rings. Comes with crotty's signature creamy onion vinaigrette
Fried Pickles
We love the salty pickle taste with the crunchy breadcrumb coating! Served with a side of ranch dressing
Chicken Fingers
Fried crispy golden-brown & served with buffalo sauce and Honey Mustard
Mozzarella Sticks
Crispy mozzarella sticks served with a side of warm marinara
Tater Tots
Bite sized shredded golden potato balls
Crispy Stuffed Baked Potato
(Not available during summer months). Our hearty stuffed baked potatoes are made by deep-frying the shell and then stuffing the inside with our butter cream mashed potatoes. Delicious on its own or stuffed with your choice of additions. Always served with
Baked Potato
Dessert
Homemade Cheesecake Bites
Deep-fried, battered cheesecake balls, covered in powdered sugar, topped with chocolate & caramel syrup
Crotty's Signature Egg Cream
Delicious chocolate beverages made the old-school way!
Milkshakes
These Extra Large 32oz Milkshakes are Decadent, Creamy, Homemade & Customizable. Your Choice of either Vanilla or Chocolate Ice Cream. Mix-ins include Oreo, Heath Bar or Chips ahoy . Finished off with Whip Cream on top.
Sport Top Poland Spring Water
Bottle Soda
Canned Beverage
Beverages
Specials
Pint-Sized Vegan's Sweet & Spicy Italian Cheesesteak!
Beyond meat, vegan cheese caramelized onions, fries, hot Italian peppers, mushrooms & sweet teriyaki sauce on a hoagie
The Iona Gael Cheesesteak
American cheese, caramelized onions, choice of protein, bacon, eggs, french fries, and ketchup
Saucy Rascals Hot Sauce
Hot sauce- a party in your mouth
Saucy Rascals Ketchup
Everyday ketchup - tangy & sweet
Saucy Rascals Premium Sauces
Best Mac N Cheese Shop
Bacon Lovers Mac & Cheese
Elbow Pasta smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce and topped with Crispy Bacon
BBQ Pulled Pork Mac & Cheese
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce and topped with our Slow Cooked BBQ Pulled Pork
Buffalo Chicken Mac & Cheese
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Buffalo Cheese Sauce Garnished with Blue Cheese
Cajun Mac & Cheese
Elbow Pasta smothered in our Spicy & Cheesy Sauce
Cheesesteak Mac & Cheese
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce with Black Angus Beef, Caramelized Onions and Whiz
Chicken Teriyaki Mac & Cheese
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce and topped with our tangy Teriyaki Chicken
Chili Mac & Cheese
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Homemade Cheese Sauce and Loaded up with our Homemade meat Chili
Classic Mac & Cheese
Elbow Pasta smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce (3 different cheeses!) and topped with Shaved Parmesan Cheese
Fresh Veggie Mac & Cheese
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Homemade Cheese Sauce and Piled High with our Chef’s selection of Fresh Veggies
Parmesan & Garlic Mac & Cheese
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Sauce which is blended with Garlic and Parmesan Cheese
Pesto Mac & Cheese
Elbow Pasta in a Creamy Pesto & Cheese Sauce