Stopped in for lunch, boy was i surprised with the new look! I love it. The place looks different, the cheesesteak I got was phenomenal and probably better than the last time I got a sandwich from here. Paul who helped me was an absolute gem, and the genius behind my delicious sandwich

Fast service, great staff and then the cheesesteak was top!! Great place for quick bite, Crotty's pulled the sandwich straight outta Philly.. better tho cuz we in NY!!

My family and I, like to order fried pickels, and the large variety of Cheesesteak Sandwiches. For people who do not eat meat or chicken, there are many tasty options such as the fried pickels, the Vegan Cheesesteaks and more. The staff and owner are very courteous, professional and caring while providing great service along with the tasty food that we always enjoy immensely.

Good food, nice people. I enjoyed traditional. Kid enjoyed nuggets off kid's menu. If you are local support your peeps. We ate in but its essentially take out with a park across the street to dine out. Will return if in the area for good eats

I had left a local record store and saw this place as I was navigating to go to the Strand Theatre in Seymour, Connecticut It was too hard to try to make a left turn so I made a right turn and then came back down and pulled into the parking lot Parking is in the back. I went through the back entrance Looked at the menu and there's all different types of cheese steaks. It's locally owned. The employee was very helpful when I went to order. I decided on the mushroom cheesesteak with onions and peppers. The guy behind the counter recommended provolone cheese. I asked if there was a combo for a cheese stick and french fries He said everything was à la carte. The cheesesteak was $13 and I decided to get the special of garlic fries for $6.95. The regular french fries were priced at $5.95. I got foxon Park soda. He said everything will be brought out to me at the table. In About 8 minutes and my cheesesteak came out with good looking garlic fries He asked if I needed any sauces I. I chose marinara sauce. The french fries looked very good and were crispy on the outside with a nice fresh potato taste. The garlic on the fries was very fresh and it didn't overpower the flavor or taste of the french fries themselves The roll was very fresh and soft. The peppers, onions, provolone cheese, and mushrooms mixed very well with the steak. Very flavorful and fresh. But not greasy sometimes cheese steak spots. The meat is pretty greasy and I don't like that. The quality of the meat and all the ingredients were very good My only criticism was that other reviewers said that it was a very hefty portion of meat. It was a good portion I thought. But not as large as some of the reviewers said it was, and I thought that the portion was a good size portion. But not as much meat as I've gotten that other cheesesteak places for around the same price $13 bucks for a cheesesteak. I see they had an option to add extra meat for $4 but I didn't think that I would of had to pick that option when I first ordered I would definitely go back here though there's so many different choices for cheesesteaks and the employee recommended the cheesesteak with extra American cheese So in conclusion, the quality of cheesesteak sandwich was very very good. The french fries were done, just right. I thought the price with the cheesesteak and the french fries which came to about $21.50 was reasonable for the quality of the entire sandwich. I just wish there was a little bit more meat in it

Hello yelp Here at Crotty's with a new review ask for by the new Owner. I just walked out after paying $25. For a foot long cheesesteak and order of onions rings. The employees was super kind and respectful 10stars now let's talk about the food the OnionRings well breaded cook perfect. The cheesesteak Flavorful! I do like more of a bite i must say I enjoyed the cheesesteak the flavor palette was well balanced when you taste the meat the cheese, whiz, the peppers, the onion, the pickles, ketchup, mayo WELL BALANCE! I enjoyed the food and looking forward to eating again

Delicious cheese steaks! We tried a few different options and all were delicious. Not the greatest parking so find what you can but totally worth it. Everyone was really nice. There were lots of options!

A huge #ThankYou to Lindsay and Joe from @crottyscheesesteaks in #NewRochelleNY for having us back to their #cheesesteak oasis. @BigDudesBigFoods was invited back to help create a cheesesteak #collab Joe and I decided on the "Big Dudes Big Foods: Meat& Potatoes Cheesesteak" = Blank Angus Beef, Sausage & #CarmelizedOnions topped with shredded provolone, #TaterTots , #OnionRings, #CheeseWhiz and #Bacon on a long roll that waited its entire life to become this masterpiece. It was a multi-napkin mass of deliciousness. Crotty's is definitely #BDBFCertified . It's a cool little corner storefront, across from a park, around the corner from #IonaCollege run by cool family with fun and courteous staff. Next time you're anywhere near New Rochelle, stop in for a bite and tell them @ BigDudesBigFoods sent you. #BigDudesBigFoods #SupportSmallBusiness #CelebrateEveryDay #globaleats #shenanigans #BDBFCertified #ThePhoneEatsFirst #Forkyeahfoodies #BDBF @forkyeahfoodies #YouDontKnowJersey #TeaseTheDay #ClearEyesFullBelliesCantLose #ABigDudesGottaDoWhatABigDudesGottaDo #HaveYouHuggedABigDudeToday #CrottysCheesesteaks

Well Well Well.... Crotty's & Yelp has created an addiction. Yelp had an event at Crotty's which introduced me to this establishment and I have now been back a few times. Even twice in the same week. (Smh) You just might miss it... but once you find it you may never forget it. Located steps away from the lona college campus in New Rochelle. I enjoy the option of grilled chicken breast since I do not eat beef. My choice is the custom...loaded on a toasted garlic hoagie with provolone cheese, caramelized onions, jalapeños, grilled tomatoes, and occasionally fried pickles. No matter if it is the shorty or the regular I am only able to eat half. The shop is small with one table for four, some out door high-tops (in warmer weather) and a window counter with seating for about 3. Small in size but with a staff that is big on personality and supper friendly and the food is definitely worth it, even if you take it to go. Thank you to Sharon, Paul, John & Harold. As well as Yelp Hudson Valley for putting Crotty's in my rotation. Just A Note: - My other 1/2 re-heats well in the toaster oven. -They are open Late and they Deliver far (their words not mine). Friday & Saturdays they are open until midnight. Great for a late night indulgence.